Worst Real Estate Agents in Middletown, New York

Agent Rankings

Rows are sorted by bad review count. The risk score is out of 10: 10 bad reviews equals 1 point, and 100 or more equals 10/10.

Current source Middletown, New York

Agent data on this page is pulled from publicly available review and profile records for this market.

Risk score Out of 10

Ten bad reviews equals one risk point. Scores are capped at 10/10 once an agent reaches 100 or more bad reviews.

Bad reviews Review-risk count

Bad-review counts represent negative client-experience signals used to rank the records on this city page.

Evidence snapshot Middletown at a glance

Ranked agents 11

Bad-review signals 650+

Highest risk 10/10

Freshness May 2026

Community signal

Had direct experience with an agent in Middletown?

Submit a confidential vote. Your email is captured for verification, but your name is not shown publicly.

11 agents in Middletown

00

#1 Worst Agent

Ryan Roberts

DFRNT Realty Group

10/10Risk score 100+Bad reviews

1

Melissa Forsyth

Hudson Valley Home Connection, LLC

10/10Risk score 100Bad reviews

2

Steve Esposito

HomeSmart Homes and Estates

9/10Risk score 90Bad reviews

3

Sharon Reynolds - REALTOR ASSOCIATE

Keller Williams Hudson Valley United

8/10Risk score 80Bad reviews

4

Rocio Weyrauch

Keller Williams Realty HVU

7/10Risk score 70Bad reviews

5

Katrina Roloson

Keller Williams Realty, First in New York

6/10Risk score 60Bad reviews

6

Israel Sanchez

Keller Williams Realty NYC group

5/10Risk score 50Bad reviews

7

George Stephenson - REALTOR ASSOCIATE

eXp Realty

4/10Risk score 40Bad reviews

8

Frances Levin

DLR Realty

3/10Risk score 30Bad reviews

9

Courtney Tablante

Keller Williams Realty First in New York

2/10Risk score 20Bad reviews

10

Brian Caplicki

Keller Williams Hudson Valley United

1/10Risk score 10Bad reviews

Middletown serves as the commercial hub of Orange County's western region, with a median home price around $310,000. The city offers commuter access to NYC via NJ Transit and Coach USA, attracting buyers seeking affordable alternatives to closer-in Hudson Valley communities.

Middletown Real Estate Market

Homes average 32 days on market. Legoland New York in nearby Goshen and the expanding healthcare corridor at Garnet Health provide local economic drivers. A Middletown agent helps buyers find value in this growing Orange County market.

Review Signals

These categories make bad-review data easier to understand in Middletown without relying on a single score alone.

Poor communication

Slow replies, unclear updates, missing context, or clients feeling ignored during the transaction.

Misleading advice

Reports that guidance, pricing expectations, or transaction details were presented in a way clients later disputed.

Pressure tactics

Clients describing rushed decisions, uncomfortable urgency, or pressure to move forward before they were ready.

Missed deadlines

Complaints involving late follow-up, missed paperwork, delayed responses, or deadline-sensitive mistakes.

Billing issues

Concerns about commission expectations, fees, payment communication, or transaction cost surprises.

Unprofessional conduct

Review themes involving respect, reliability, conduct, conflict handling, or client care.

Consumer guidance

What to do before choosing an agent in Middletown

01Compare the risk score with the bad-review count instead of relying on the score alone.

02Look for repeated complaint themes, especially communication, pressure, and missed deadlines.

03Check whether the agent's brokerage, market, and recent profile data match the transaction you need help with.

04Use the investigation form if a record looks fake, misleading, private, or unrelated to a real client experience.

Nearby Pages

Related city links are generated from the same state dataset.

01 Albany New York 10 02 Amsterdam New York 10 03 Auburn New York 10 04 Beacon New York 10 05 Binghamton New York 10 06 Buffalo New York 10 07 Cortland New York 10 08 Elmira New York 10 09 Freeport New York 10 10 Glen Cove New York 10 11 Goshen New York 10 12 Hempstead New York 10

See something that's not right?

If you believe a review or ranking is fake, misleading, from someone who was not a client, contains private information or violates our review policy, you can request an investigation here.

FAQ

Common questions about Middletown rankings, source records, and community votes.

How are agents selected for Middletown?

Agents are included based on publicly available profile and review data for Middletown. They're ranked by the number of negative reviews on record, with the highest-risk agents listed first.

What does the risk score mean?

The risk score is a simple measure of how many complaints an agent has. For every 10 bad reviews, one point is added to their score, up to a maximum of 10/10. A higher score means more negative client experiences are on record.

Are community votes public?

No. Your vote is completely confidential. We collect your email to verify the submission and prevent abuse, but your name is never requested or shown anywhere on the site.

Can an agent challenge a listing?

Yes. Any agent, or anyone else, can request an investigation if they believe a listing is inaccurate, misleading, or based on a fake review. We review every request and will correct or remove records that don't meet our review policy.